19th Century (1848–1899)

1848, 1849, 1850, 1856 — Robert Hurd
1851, 1852, 1854 — Amos Haines McKay
1853, 1855, 1857, 1859, 1864, 1865, 1869, 1870, 1873 — Jacob Randall
1858 — Isaac E. Keys
1860 — Jacob T. McKay
1861, 1862, 1863 — Thomas Larue (La Rue) Allen
1866, 1867, 1876, 1877, 1885, 1886, 1887, 1893 — William Jones
1868 — Dr. Samuel J. Way
1871, 1872, 1881 — T. T. Dodson
1874, 1875 — George W. Hamilton
1878, 1882 — John N. Fetter
1879, 1880 — Charles Dorsey Wooley
1883, 1884 — James A. Kearney
1888, 1889 — John Jacob Mosher
1890, 1891 — George R. Stiles
 1892 — Charles L. Conger
1894, 1895, 1896 — Dr. James W. Ward
1897, 1898 — George Edward Randall 1899 — John T. Brown

Early 20th Century (1900–1949)

1900, 1901 — James Edwin Janney
1902, 1903, 1904 — Madison McKinsey
1905, 1906 — Howard E. Booth
1907, 1908 — Warren H. Keys
1909, 1910, 1915 — John O. Cartwright
1911, 1912 — Fred B. Henderson
1913, 1914 — Dr. Jacob Tressler Ellis
1916, 1917 — D. Lester Crane
1918, 1919 — Samuel Dinwiddie Henkle
1920 — John Collett Hawke
 1921 — J. Wilson Edwards
 1922, 1936 — D. Ralph Smith
1923, 1924, 1942 — Kenneth N. Hough
1925 — George James Waterhouse
1926, 1940 — Jesse James Prendergast
1927, 1928 — Charles E. Bradbury
1929, 1945 — Earl Forrest Thomas
1930, 1941 — Ross Hebert Hartsock, 33°
1931 — Paul Boorom
1932 — Vern M. Armitage
1933 — Lewis C. St. John
1934, 1935 — Ethan Crane
1937 — Emerson F. Earnhart
1938, 1939 — Raymond W. Braddock
1943 — Harold B. Earnhart
1944 — James Carl Conard
1946, 1947 — Merlyn Banta
1948 — William P. Strader
1949 — Roger Brown

Mid–Late 20th Century (1950–1999)

1950 — Jon Gons
1951 — Donald Hawke
1952 — John Sheehan
1953 — Cecil Davis
1954 — Loren James Hopkins
1955 — William Penewit
1956 — Joseph E. James
1957 — Milo Beal
1958 — William Strouse
1959 — Lawrence H. Weller, 33°
1960 — Woodrow Rowland
1961 — John Robert Palmer
 1962 — James Bourne
1963, 1965 — James C. Douglas
1964, 1969 — Charles Earl Elzey
 1966 — Harold E. Walker
1967 — James M. Burnett
1968, 1979, 1980, 1983 — Grover W. Brunton, 33°
1970 — Joseph C. Helton
1971, 1972 — Robert E. Worthington, 33°
1973, 1978 — E. Stephen Conner
1974 — Darrell Dean “Pete” Duffey
 1975, 1976 — Robert Lee Maybury
1977 — Frank Gruber
 1981 — Charles A. Harrah
 1982 — George M. Lawson, Sr.
1984 — Barry Milton Miller
1985 — James W. Crane
1986 — Randal Allen Anderson, Jr.
1987, 1996, 1997 — Raymond W. Lewis, Jr.
1988 — Jack C. Sowder
1989 — Jerrold D. Plummer
1990, 2015, 2018 — Dennis E. Kearns
1991 — Johnie Calvin Coffman
1992, 1994 — David E. W. Brunotte, Sr.
1993 — James Robert Frost
1995 — Richard E. Powell
1998 — John Edward Lewis 1999 — Clarence Risner

21st Century (2000–2026)

2000 — Kevin Paul Rathweg
2001 — Stephen Douglas Gibson
2002 — Larry M. Cornett
2003 — Larry B. Cornett
2004 — Bradley Stephen Conner
2005 — Nathan Kearns
2006 — Bryan Gerald Wilson
2007 — Mark Mason
2008 — Terry James Tincher
2009 — Gavin Whitaker
2010 — Kevin Lee Williams
 2011 — Christopher Jones
2012, 2014 — Everett Bradford
2013 — Michael Dennis Wonderly, II
2016 — Chad A. Johnson
2017 — Stephen C. Johnson
2019 — George H. Pena
2020 — L. “Andy” Ray
2021 — Larry M. Tobias
 2022 — Gabriel J. Plummer
2023 — Matthew Petersen
2024 — Joshua Baker
2025, 2026 — Brian L. Hartman